Guild icon
Tulpa.info
Tulpa Discussion / tulpa-discussion
The channel for discussion strictly on the topic of tulpas. Take off-topic discussion to #lounge Forum's Tulpa Discussion Board: https://community.tulpa.info/forum/4-general-discussion/
Avatar
@Deleted User I'm actually not super pro science, for the record. STEM oversteps its boundaries, and what I'm suggesting isn't even science so much as it is philosophical inquiry.
5:43 PM
>main priorities
5:43 PM
they aren't ever the priority.
5:43 PM
They aren't ever any sort of priority.
5:43 PM
They are always pushed aside in favor of mucking about on the internet.
Avatar
Deleted User 6/20/2018 5:44 PM
You know, people have different priorities. Some of them want their waifu talk to them, not doing science/philosophy.
Avatar
The fact that there's never any actual argumentation going on should be proof of that.
5:44 PM
@Deleted User but no one?
5:44 PM
I can't get anyone to engage with my thoughts on this because everyone is always telling me they don't have discovery as a priority.
Avatar
[giggle I mean even this is an argument 😄]
Avatar
I feel like I'm not being unreasonable in being upset that I can't actually engage anyone on something I care a whole hell of a lot about.
5:45 PM
Silina this isn't an argument regarding the mechanics of a tulpa
5:45 PM
which is what I was talking about.
Avatar
Deleted User 6/20/2018 5:45 PM
Some of them just don't care. Get over it. Of course, it's questionable if those people should be in charge (I'm not accusing anyone from staff here)
Avatar
[I'd argue with you! But that would be kinda boring being like the 10th time going through the same arguments]
Avatar
Yeah, because you don't argue, silina
5:46 PM
and see here is the fucking
5:46 PM
prime example situation
Avatar
[Yes I do! (that's an argument)]
Avatar
Abvieon {Alex} 6/20/2018 5:46 PM
I see argumentation going on a lot in tulpa communities, and in fact for the past year or so I've only seen it increase from the past. Though I think it was a bit more common than it is now in the 2012 era, and after that experienced a dip, and has recently started to come back up (edited)
Avatar
Silina is telling me that they'll argue with me. For reference, they always assert a position, refuse to justify it in the face of questions, and then giggle and prod at me like i'm an idiot for expecting legitimate argumentation.
Avatar
Are you arguing for the sake of arguing/feelings, or because you have something substantial backing you up?
Avatar
I look like an asshole who isn't actually taking up the offer of an argument, even though I know it will go nowhere
5:47 PM
this is fucking cancer
Avatar
Abvieon {Alex} 6/20/2018 5:48 PM
I do think people should care more about the mechanics of tulpas and think more in depth, though, it's true that a lot of people don't care at all. It's not really a problem in my eyes, it'd just be nice if people cared more about discovering more about tulpas
Avatar
Don't tell me to get over it when I legitimately take on negative social reputation because I give a shit about something and can't counteract the anti-thought that is so prevalent in these conversations
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:48 PM
I would be interested in comparing theories about the mechanics of how tulpas roll
Avatar
[Hey I justify! It's just the justifications are of the kind that are particularly hard to argue against.]
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:49 PM
But an argument being "hard to argue against" can have reasons other than "it's a good argument"
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:49 PM
It could be "that argument misses the point"
Avatar
@Ruethus the Silver Sorceror let's talk shop sometime soon!
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:49 PM
Or "that argument doesn't actually say anything", one I've seen thrown out far too often
5:49 PM
I would love to discuss theory
Avatar
unfortunately this is sort of the channel for the topic we'd be discussing
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:50 PM
Gotta figure out what I've accidentally created so that I can plan for what to do in the future
Avatar
@Ruethus the Silver Sorceror So I've been working on how to deal with the issues associated with claiming physicalism with respect to consciousness and therefore tulpas.
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:51 PM
Physicalism?
5:51 PM
I don't know that term
5:52 PM
I'm quite new to this community, for reference
Avatar
Um, claiming that nothing exists outside of the physical.
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:52 PM
Ah, I see. (edited)
Avatar
That's okay, physicalism is outside the community. It's a philosophy term.
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:52 PM
Programmer arguments can be rolled out then (edited)
Avatar
Maybe. I'm no programmer.
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:53 PM
That's my chosen profession, and boy oh boy does it shape my philosophy
Avatar
Hell yeah, you can tell me if I'm sounding like a dumbass, maybe!
5:53 PM
Aight, so basically, when I claim physicalism, a few problems crop up
Avatar
[Is there even a problem physicalism has with tulpas? Neurons fire, stuff happens.]
Avatar
I've gotta outline what consciousness is in a physicalist framework, and then I've got to work tulpas into this framework.
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:54 PM
Alright, so I roll with a three-part model of how a "being" works. The three parts are the actual body, the subconscious and senses, and the "mind"
Avatar
I can elaborate on all of that if you want, but I'm currently at a point where i consider consciousness to arise in varying degrees of complexity based on the "hardware"
5:54 PM
oh
5:54 PM
if you wanna go first that's fine
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:56 PM
The body is the physical form, and communicates with the mind via senses and the subconscious (this is an abstract grouping, so some things aren't entirely one-to-one here). Typical interactions are the body informing the mind of its current situation, and the mind sending back commands to respond to it.
Avatar
So you're not a physicalist.
Avatar
Abvieon {Alex} 6/20/2018 5:56 PM
@Mauriby This may be an interesting read for you: https://redd.it/8ao8kv
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:56 PM
Not particularly
5:57 PM
Physicalism is a Devil's Proof in my eyes
Avatar
That may be problematic since I pretty strongly disagree with non physicalist positions wrt consciousness.
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:57 PM
Although my model currently assumes the mind is simply an instance of a learning machine hosted by the body
5:57 PM
Which should meet the requirements of physicalism
5:58 PM
And that makes what tulpas are quite clear: they're simply additional instances of learning machines sharing mental real estate
Avatar
If that's the case, then the body includes the mind.
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:58 PM
Indeed
Avatar
okay so
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:58 PM
But I'm abstracting out based on function
Avatar
you kinda are halfassing your foundational assumptions
5:58 PM
but that's okay
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:58 PM
Well... bear in mind I hadn't dabbled much with this until a month or two ago
Avatar
that's why it's okay!
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 5:59 PM
Also, I need to find better words to describe the divisions
Avatar
In general, I find if you're doing too much abstracting, you might wanna look into things a bit more deeply. Let me write up some thoughts on your system as presented
6:01 PM
could you explain to me what a learning machine is?
6:01 PM
I think I know but I want to be sure
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 6:01 PM
It's a programming term for an artificial intelligence
6:01 PM
But I use it without the assumptions that it's a human-constructed device
Avatar
okay, so how does a learning machine kickstart a second learning machine?
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 6:02 PM
Sharing records of past work (edited)
Avatar
aight, I can actually probably work with this
6:03 PM
I'd delineate everything differently than you, but I think we probably agree at the base level on how this stuff works
6:03 PM
biggest issue I see is that you're definitely using dualistic language for a non dualistic position, which is confusing and problematic
6:03 PM
since people will not grasp the actual argument you're putting forth and will instead warp it into their dualistic framework
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 6:04 PM
I suspect that's due to me considering the body "hardware" and what people think of as consciousness as "software"
Avatar
Nah, I agree with that metaphor, actually
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 6:04 PM
And not always making clear when I'm referring to the software or the hardware hosting it
Avatar
may i try and outline some stuff real quick?
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 6:05 PM
Go ahead
Avatar
So, if there's nothing outside the physical realm, then consciousness is a purely physical phenomenon.
6:06 PM
If that's the case, then I have to figure out what I believe about consciousness.
6:06 PM
As of right now, I believe that consciousness is the "side effect" of biochemical processes.
6:07 PM
Ants have a very low-complexity form of this "consciousness," etc. Humans have a fairly high-complexity form of this "consciousness."
6:07 PM
Because of this, I don't like talking about tulpas like they're another consciousness, because I see consciousness as a state of being rather than some discrete separable thingy.
6:09 PM
Consciousness is also embodied, as far as I can tell. What I mean by this is that if I'm driving my truck, which is a manual, I'm going to be physically doing things (pushing in the clutch, shifting, letting off the clutch while easing forward with the gas, etc) as well as mentally doing things (thinking about how I want to get to Wendy's, what I want to eat, wondering whether or not I have a turn signal bulb out, etc).
6:09 PM
Both of these are consciousness.
Avatar
Ruethus the Silver Sorceror 6/20/2018 6:09 PM
Oh hey, a fellow stick driver
Avatar
( ;) )
6:10 PM
So reflexes, like swatting a bumblefucker who ambushes you behind your glasses, are also consciousness
6:10 PM
I don't use consciousness in opposition to subconscious/unconscious, as I'm talking about a state of being, not a subsection of the "mind"
6:10 PM
I have no interest in the "mind" when it comes to tulpas.
Exported 100 message(s)
Timezone: UTC+0
Page 1 ... Page 114 ... Page 115 ... Page 116 ... Page 999